Reynolds graduated Oak Park High School in 1983 and then moved on to the University of Central Missouri where he graduated in 1987. He began his coaching career at Belton in 1990. Reynolds moved to North Kansas City in 1995 before landing at Park Hill in 1998.
Reynolds was named the head coach for the Trojans in 2000 and led the team to a 104-44 record in 13 seasons. During that time Park Hill won six conference titles, nine district championships, advanced to the quarterfinals six times and won the Missouri Class 5 state title in 2003. He returned to the program as an assistant coach in 2015.
During Reynolds career he was named the Missouri Class 5 Coach of the Year, served on the GKCFCA executive board for eight years and was the president of the association for two years.